It’s 4:40 on a Friday. An email from “Microsoft 365” says your mailbox is almost full. You click, a sign-in page appears, you type your password, and the page just reloads. Something feels off.
First, you are not alone, and you are not the first. Falling for a phishing email takes less than a minute: in Verizon’s phishing tests, the median person clicked 21 seconds after opening the message and typed their details 28 seconds later.[1] Phishing and spoofing drew more complaints to the FBI in 2025 than any other crime, more than 190,000 of them.[2]
What matters now is what you do next. Here is how to tell how serious it is, what to do step by step, and what your IT team should check behind the scenes.
If you clicked a phishing link: close the page without typing anything else, disconnect from the network if a file downloaded, and call IT right away. If you entered a password, change it from a different device and have IT sign you out of every session and check your mailbox for new rules. If you gave bank details, call your bank first.
First: what exactly did you do?
How worried to be depends on what happened after the click. Find the line that matches yours.
You clicked, then closed the page
If you did not type anything or download anything, the damage is usually limited. Usually is not never: the FTC warns that a link itself can carry malware.[3] Tell IT anyway, and let them scan your computer.
You typed your password
Assume someone else now has it. Whoever runs the fake page can try to sign in as you to email, files and anything else that uses that password. Change it now and tell IT.
You opened a file or something downloaded
This is how malware gets onto a computer. Disconnect from the network and call IT before you do anything else on that machine.
You typed your password and a login code, or approved a prompt
Some fake pages pass your login through to the real site and steal the “you are signed in” session along the way. Microsoft is clear that this is not a flaw in MFA.[4] It does mean a password change alone may not lock the attacker out.
You gave bank or card details, or sent money
Call your bank or card company first, before anything else on this page. The FTC says to report it to your bank immediately and ask them to reverse the payment.[5]
What to do, step by step
Do these in order. The first three matter most.
Stop and close the page.
Do not type anything else, and do not try to “finish” whatever the page was asking for. Do not delete the email either. IT needs it to see who else got the same message.
If a file opened or downloaded, disconnect.
Turn off Wi-Fi or unplug the network cable. Leave the computer on so IT can see what happened.
Tell IT right away, by phone or in person.
Speed matters. In one case Microsoft studied, attackers started trying to steal money within five minutes of stealing a login.[4] Call rather than email, because if your mailbox is compromised, someone else may be reading it. Microsoft gives admins the same advice about new passwords: never send them by email.[6]
Change the password from a different device.
Use a computer or phone you trust, not the one you clicked on. If you used the same password anywhere else, change it there too.[5]
Have IT sign you out everywhere.
In Microsoft 365, your administrator can sign you out of every session and check that no strange phone or app was added to your login. A sign-in can keep working for up to an hour after a password change unless sessions are revoked.[7]
Check for new email rules.
Attackers often add a rule that forwards your mail to them, or hides replies so you never see them.[6] IT can find hidden rules that do not show up in Outlook.
Deny any login prompt you did not start.
An unexpected approval request on your phone means someone has your password. Deny it and tell IT. Attackers sometimes send prompt after prompt hoping someone taps “Approve” to make it stop, and Verizon found that worked in more than 20% of these attacks.[8]
Write down what happened.
What time you clicked, what the page looked like, what you typed. Two minutes of notes now saves hours later.
Opens a one-page desk card of these steps to print or save. Fill in your IT phone number and post it where everyone can see it.
(586) 533-2081
hello@wizcomltd.com
// Keep this by your desk
Clicked a Suspicious Link?
Do not panic, and do not keep quiet. Work through this list and call IT right away. Reporting fast is what limits the damage.
Right now
- Close the page. Do not type anything else. Do not delete the email.
- If a file opened or downloaded: turn off Wi-Fi or unplug the cable. Leave the computer on.
- Call IT (do not email). Say what you clicked and what you typed.
Next
- Change the password from a different, trusted device, and anywhere else you used it
- IT signs you out of all sessions and checks your login methods
- IT checks for new forwarding or inbox rules
- Deny any login prompt you did not start, and tell IT
If money or personal information is involved
- Call the bank or card company immediately and ask them to reverse the payment
- Report fraud at ic3.gov; personal information at IdentityTheft.gov
Report it
- Outlook: Home > Report > Report Phishing (or forward to reportphishing@apwg.org)
- Write down the time, the page and what you typed
Why changing your password isn’t always enough
Most people think a new password locks the attacker out. Often it does. But modern phishing kits do something sneakier.
The fake page sits between you and the real Microsoft sign-in. You type your password and your code, the real site lets you in, and the fake page quietly copies the session that proves you are signed in. With that, the attacker is signed in as you, no password or code needed.[4] Among attacks on Microsoft 365 that got around MFA, Verizon found stealing those sign-in sessions was the most common method, at 31%.[8]
That is why the fix has more than one step. Microsoft’s own playbook for a compromised mailbox has the administrator reset the password, revoke every active session, review the phones and apps tied to the login, and check for new forwarding and inbox rules.[6] In Microsoft’s case study, attackers created a rule that moved the victim’s replies into the Archive folder and marked them read, so the victim never saw the conversation the attacker was having in their name.[4]
None of this means MFA is useless. It still stops most password attacks. It means a stolen login is a job for IT, not just a password reset.
What your IT team should check in Microsoft 365
If you manage IT, or want to know what to ask your IT provider, this is the short version of Microsoft’s response checklist for a compromised account:[6]
- Reset the password, or disable the account while you investigate
- Revoke all active sessions so every device has to sign in again
- Remove any phone, authenticator app or security key the user does not recognize
- Review apps the user gave permission to, and remove anything unfamiliar
- Check forwarding and inbox rules, including hidden ones
- Check sign-in history for unusual places and times, and Sent Items for messages the user did not send
One detail trips people up: app passwords created for older email programs are not removed when the main password changes, so they have to be checked separately.[6] If nobody at your business owns this list, that is a gap worth closing. It is a big part of what managed IT services covers.
Who to report it to
| Who | When | How |
|---|---|---|
| Your IT team | Always, and first | Report Phishing button in Outlook, plus a phone call if you clicked or typed anything |
| Your bank or card company | You gave payment details or sent money | The number on the back of your card or on your statement. The FBI says to ask for a recall or reversal as soon as you spot fraud.[11] |
| FBI | Money was lost, or it is a business email scam | ic3.gov[11] |
| FTC | Any phishing or scam | ReportFraud.ftc.gov, and IdentityTheft.gov if you gave out personal information like a Social Security number[5] |
| Anti-Phishing Working Group | Any phishing email | Forward it to reportphishing@apwg.org[10] |
| Your phone carrier | A scam text message | Forward the text to 7726 (SPAM)[3] |
| Michigan State Police (MC3) | A business cyber incident in Michigan | 877-MI-CYBER or mc3@michigan.gov[12] |
For owners: make it safe to say “I clicked”
The person who clicked is your fastest alarm. Every minute they spend wondering whether to tell anyone is a minute the attacker keeps.
The UK’s National Cyber Security Centre puts it bluntly: avoid a culture of blame around phishing, because “employees who are afraid for their jobs will not report mistakes.”[13] Training helps, but mostly with reporting. In Verizon’s data, recently trained employees reported phishing about four times as often as the baseline, while their click rates barely moved.[8] Some people will always click. The goal is that they tell someone right away.
- Make reporting one click: turn on the Report button in Outlook and tell everyone it is there
- Thank people who report, including the ones who clicked
- Post one phone number for “I clicked something” and make sure someone answers it
- Set up Microsoft 365 so a stolen password alone is not enough to get in
Our plain-English guide to Zero Trust covers the sign-in protections that make a stolen password much less useful, and what happens during a ransomware attack shows how often a phished password is step one.
How to spot the next one: 7 warning signs
Bad spelling used to be the giveaway. Not anymore: CISA notes that AI now helps scammers write clean, convincing messages.[14] Watch for these instead.
- It is urgent or scary. Your account will be closed, a payment failed, there was “suspicious activity.” Pressure is the point.[14]
- It asks you to sign in or confirm details. Especially through a link in the message.[3]
- There is an invoice or payment you do not recognize. Or a link to “pay now.”[3]
- The sender or link is slightly wrong. A misspelled company name, a free email address, or a link that goes somewhere other than where it says. Hover before you click.[14]
- The link is shortened or hidden. Short links and QR codes hide where they really go.[14]
- A familiar name asks for something unusual. Your boss wants gift cards. A vendor has “new bank details.” Call them on a number you already have.[3]
- It arrives by text or phone call. Phishing is not just email. In Verizon’s 2026 data, people in phishing tests fell for text and voice messages 40% more often than email.[15]
When in doubt, do not use the link or phone number in the message. Go to the website or call the number you already know.[3]
Frequently asked questions
What happens if you click a phishing link but don’t enter anything?
Usually the risk is lower, because most phishing pages need you to type a password or open a file to do damage. It is not zero: a link can carry malware. Close the page, tell IT, and let them scan your computer.
I entered my password on a phishing site. What should I do?
Change the password right away from a different device, change it anywhere else you used it, and tell IT. In Microsoft 365, ask IT to sign you out of all sessions and check your mailbox for new forwarding or inbox rules, because a password change alone may not lock an attacker out.
Does MFA protect me if I entered my password on a fake page?
Usually it stops attackers who only have your password. But some fake sign-in pages pass your login through to the real site and steal your session, even if you entered a code. If you entered a code or approved a prompt on a suspicious page, treat it as a stolen login and call IT.
Should I delete a phishing email?
Report it first. Use the Report Phishing button in Outlook or tell IT, so they can find and remove the same message from everyone else’s inbox. Then delete it.
Will I get in trouble for clicking a phishing link?
You should not. Security agencies like the UK’s National Cyber Security Centre warn businesses against blaming people who click, because people who fear punishment stop reporting. Reporting fast is what limits the damage.
Where do I report a phishing email?
Inside your company, use the Report Phishing button in Outlook or tell IT. Anyone can forward phishing emails to reportphishing@apwg.org, forward scam texts to 7726, and report scams to the FTC at ReportFraud.ftc.gov. If money was lost, contact your bank and file a report at ic3.gov.
Make the Next Click Less Costly
For more than 40 years, Wizcom has helped Michigan businesses keep their technology safe and running. We can set up Microsoft 365 so a stolen password alone is not enough, make reporting easy for your team, and make sure someone is watching for the warning signs in this article.
Schedule Your Free IT Strategy SessionSources
- 1. Verizon, 2024 Data Breach Investigations Report, May 2024.
- 2. FBI Internet Crime Complaint Center, 2025 Internet Crime Report, Apr. 2026.
- 3. Federal Trade Commission, How to Recognize and Avoid Phishing Scams, Sept. 2022.
- 4. Microsoft Threat Intelligence, From cookie theft to BEC: Attackers use AiTM phishing sites as entry point to further financial fraud, July 12, 2022.
- 5. Federal Trade Commission, What To Do if You Were Scammed, June 2026.
- 6. Microsoft Learn, Respond to a compromised email account, updated July 2026.
- 7. Microsoft Learn, Revoke user access in an emergency in Microsoft Entra ID, accessed October 13, 2026.
- 8. Verizon, 2025 Data Breach Investigations Report, Apr. 2025.
- 9. Microsoft Support, Report phishing and suspicious emails in Outlook, accessed October 13, 2026.
- 10. Anti-Phishing Working Group, Report Phishing, accessed October 13, 2026.
- 11. FBI Internet Crime Complaint Center, Business Email Compromise, accessed October 13, 2026.
- 12. Michigan State Police, Michigan Cyber Command Center (MC3), accessed October 13, 2026.
- 13. UK National Cyber Security Centre, Phishing attacks: defending your organisation, accessed October 13, 2026.
- 14. CISA, Recognize and Report Phishing, accessed October 13, 2026.
- 15. Verizon, 2026 Data Breach Investigations Report, Executive Summary, May 2026.
Sources checked October 13, 2026. Figures are as reported by each source.



